Evgency (Eugene) PODKLETNOV, Antigravity and Space-X

HOME PAGE Code Glossary & Basics Contents 1: Current-Events Contents 2: Code&Ark Issues Contents 3B: Other Mars Science Contents 3A: MarsCorrect Contents 4: UFOs Contents 5: President Trump Contents 6: Obama Contents 7: Israel Ryan's Health care fails Westminster Attack THAAD missile shield Korean Atomic War Obama wiretaps Trump Enemy News Trump, Musk & Mars Fort Huachuca Trump, Enemy Media & Insomnia TRAPPIST-1  Solar System General H. R. McMaster Tom Price & ObamaCare Repeal Australia& Obama attack America Mike Pompeo at CIA Jared Kushner Manning Sentenced CIA's John Brennan Ft. Lauderdale ISIS Airport Shooter DNC Hacker: Putin or Netanyahu Alien Virus & Politics Trump: Embassy to Jerusalem Netanyahu: Israel out of U.N.? Close the U.N. Karlov assassination Carrie Fisher as Leah Aleppo, Syria Obama Birth Trump Administration General Mattis: SECDEF? Trump picks Viola For Army Obama's Gay Sec. Army Tilllerson as Secretary of State Frozen sea on Mars Mars MAVEN Trump&Romney General Flynn Trump & Mexico Trump&Prejudice Trump Elected? TRUMP PICKS PENCE Steve Bannon Trump's Wife Trump & Kelly Bimbo Obama, Clinton, Trump & Mental Illness Donald Trump in 2016? Trump&Obama Blumenthal & Birthers Oct 5 TV interview SpaceX Failure - Sabotage? Clinton Stroke? Kaepernick Treason ZIKA Weiner Saga Obama kills flag pledge? N.Y. Iman Murdered Debbie Shultz fired as predicted Ali Sonboli - Munich killer Clinton EMail & FBI Comey Micah Johnson: Cop Killer MSL's 2 MARTIAN YEARS Senator Perdue Obama prayer HAIL BRITANNIA! Omar Mateen & Obama Muhammad Ali RADIO INTERVIEW 5/8/2016 Mars Powerpoint Katie Couric Lies General Milley Fighting ETs & Hyrbids 2016 Election Romney tries convention theft PRINCE DEATH Hot Mars Info Contents 3B: Mars Codes UFO Hypnosis Alien President Obama - Reptilian Alien? Obama in Cuba Time Experiment Garland&Obama Targeting Iran Scalia Murder? Bloomberg in 2016 Martian Life seen by MSL? Christian Values & Election Oldest Person Running water on Mars Mars Weather on 682 days Contents: People Nimr A-Nimr Beheaded Space X Lands Podkletnov update Netanyahu Kills Samir Kuntar Pope: No Jewish Conversion Russian Beheaded Turkey downs Russian Jet Pollard Matrices Jihadi John & Paris Metrojet Crash America Fallen Iran's General Soleimani James Webb in 2016: Surprise? Boehner Out, Ryan In Destruction of Rome Nuke War Date? Bin Laden&O'Neill TIANJIN EXPLOSION Huckabee & Kim Davis NASA Achilles Heel World War 3 Date Lights on Ceres Gays & World War Excommunicate 3 Justices No Strategy Obama Lincoln Chafee in 2016 Bob Jindal in 2016? John Kasich in 2016? Ben Carson 2016? Lindsey Graham in 2016 George Pataki in 2016? Bernie Sanders in 2016? Martin O'Malley in 2016? Vatican recognizes Palestine Carly Fiorina in 2016? Clinton Foundation Korean Defense Minister Shot Freddie Gray Riot USS Roosevelt to Yemen Obama Surrender Gilbert Levin found Mars Life Valerie Jarrett Bergdahl &Obama Impeachment? Palestinian State? Obama Traitor & Iran Boehner invites Netanyahu Netanyahu Says NO to Obama Netanyahu&UN NETANYAHU Satanic Obama's enemies Anti-Semite Obama Algae/Oxygen on Mars? Podesta UFO Disclosure UFO Disclosure Pelosi and Netanyahu Pharaoh Obama Jordanian Pilot LT Kateasbeh Japanese beheaded Livni vs. Netanyahu Air Asia Crash 2015 DATES Jan. 1, 2015 Charlie Hebdo Communist Obama & Cuba Ferguson Verdict 1st Ferguson Riot Eric Holder Dr. Brandenburg: Nuke on Mars Moshe Feiglin - future Prime Minister? ISIS, Kassig, & Obama Executive Action & Impeachment Time Machine and Ezekiel O'NEILL SHOOTS BIN LADEN Elon Musk & Sabotage Gaza Buffer Zone Islam attacks Ottawa Kim Jong Un Comet Siding-Spring Tom Duncan Ebola to US India & Mars Ebola Obama Khorasan in Syria Alton Nolen Beheads Scotland Votes NY Nuke Nightmare Pistorius Trial Is Obama Our Enemy? Is Obama Really Hamas? Cameron vs. Obama Israel&ISIS Sotloff Beheaded Foley Beheaded Obama & Mind Reading Computer Logistics & Gaza War Joan Rivers Robin Williams Voices from the Cosmos Birthday UFO Gaza 2014 War Gaza Children Netanyahu launches Protective Edge at Gaza Contents 7: Science &Tech DEAD SEA SCROLL CODES ON TV Roffman Code Radio Show Talmud&Names Malaysia Flight 17 Al- Maliki & Defeat in Iraq Why Cantor Lost Jay Carney Repulsine Drive Potter UFO 1 Michael Sam Boko Haram Donald Sterling Malaysia 370 shot down? Ranch War? Malaysia Airlines Air France Malaysia Pilot Zaharie Shaw Ukraine, Russia & War President Snowden? Kerry Messianic Snake Salvation Death Belarus  & ObamaCare Mars Rock Mystery Pot President Roffman Mars Radio Show Justin Bieber Minimum Wage Duck Dynasty Bush in 2016 Clinton 2016 Biden in 2016 Cruz in 2016 Christie in 2016? Ryan in 2016 Rand Paul 2016 Romney 2016 Rubio 2016 Walker in 2016 Santorum 2016 Perry in 2016 Cuomo in 2016 Warren 2016 Satanic Obama Cure to Aging? Polygamy China Crisis Iran-Nuke-Deal 2014 Dates Encoded 911:Atomic-Iran Keep-your-plan? Sebelius&Obama Nelson Mandela Comet-Ison-Fear End of America Janet Yellen Kenya-Mall-Terror PUTIN OP-ED Armageddon Assad Holocaust Putin, Obama, Assad & Enemies Israeli Intel vs. Assad Mubarak Freed? Mubarak Death? McCain & Morsi MAJOR HASAN Bill O'Reilly Fear  of Obama Zimmerman Free Flood on Mars Politics alters Mars weather Egypt's ElBaradei Army Suicide Mullah Omar TWA FLIGHT 800 Gay Scouting? Tornado Chasers Swiss against Kosher food ALLAH AKBAR & Mickey Mouse Jodo Arias Mars Cover-up & Obama N. Korea & Boston Where is God? Obama-Assad Bombers Found GUANTANAMO Nuke Korea Hagel&Korea Kim Jong Un Warship Sunk Korea Attack Erich VonDaniken Brain Mapping JC Stomp Mars Hoax Knives on Jets Obama&Israel New Pope Cardinal Mahoney Chavez&Obama Pope Resigns Rick Perry 2018 Mars mission crew Slideshows for Codes & Mars Asteroid 2012da14 School Shooting Fordo Iran Nuke Hit? Dr. Afrida 2013 Dates Encoded Lance Armstrong Hitler Escaped? Mars Coverup Doomsday Benghazi&Rice UFO Hacker Clark McClelland Arafat Polonium Election&Code  Lessons Biased News Babylon, America &Obama 2012 Election Stevens Murder Rubio, Gays & Catchism World War 3 Identity Chips Obama=Nuke War Arab Riots Mars One Way Batman Shooter Assad Update  Iran Overdue Fast&Furious Time & Boson Tachyon Time Prometheus Zionist Threat? Breitbart Death New Party Nuclear Talks Flame Virus Stuxnet Virus Obama&Gays Chaplain Woes Attack Iran? Ending Muslim Terror USS Cole Reagan&UFOs 2012 & The End of Days End of Days Romney vs. Obama Obama vs. Court Hunger Games Obama Open Mic Threat Analysis Master of Fate Nuke Iran Foreign Aid Russian Veto Panetta&War Iranian Threat Atomic Threat Brewer's Finger Mitt Romney War in Hormuz WAR in 2012 EMP Attack Malcolm X & Obama Nuke Murder Concordia Sinks Israel to Moon Rocket Sabotage 2012 Republicans Atom. Holocaust Missile Base Attack Isfahan Attack Iran is Gog Rabbi Levin Reversing Time Altering Time Iran War Plan Qaddafi Death Kaddafi Execution Solyndra Loan DEFINE ELS Aldrin&Obama Obama Alias EXODUS ROUTE Pakistan&Osama Scott Jones&ET BinLaden Dead 2012 ELECTION Obama's Failure UFO Teleportation Gravitics&Time Baptism Annulled (Spiritual Custody) Define ELS-Map Alien DNA No Alien gods! Winds of Mars 2012 Supernova? Obama History Dual Citizen Obama's School Barry Soetoro 251.565 MAPS ARK HISTORY Expedition Pics ELS MAP 1 ELS Map 2 ELS MAP 3 ELS MAP 4 ELS MAP 5 ELS MAP 11 ELS MAP 12 ELS MAP 13 ELS MAP 14 ELS MAP 15 ELS MAP 16 EXPEDITIONS ETHIOPIA&ARK Tanis&the Ark Who's a Jew? Tree of Life 2012 Dates Encoded Ron Wyatt & Saudi Sinai Vatican&Hitler Vatican Rule Jack Lu: The Finance Jew Act of God & Election Ukraine Riots Rosetta Comet Landing Boston Marathon Sue Bradley OBAMACARE Shutdown Secession Vote? Obama hoax? NewYork Curse Major Hassan Hitler Youth Code Hypothesis United States Ariel Sharon Netanyahu Wins, Yair Lapid 2nd McChrystal Fired Obama Security Apartheid Israel? Obama, Muslim King of Sodom Obama Brother Sgt Bob Bales Korean Execution Mars Lies Ishmael's Birth Sochi Terror Gas Masks in Israel Korans Burned New Gaza War Gaza Jabari Hit Assad's Missiles Chris Dorner Piers Morgan: Amend Bible? Khalid Mansour 8-27-2012 GOP Convention Egypt's Election Attack via Azerbaijan Philadelphi Rt. Paul Ryan Whitney Houston Nazarene-wife Asteroid Toutatis Mayan Doomsday Holdings Book Ahmadinejad in Space Korean Rocket Coach Sandusky Armstrong&Moon Armada vs. Iran Qaddaffi son killed Romney&Bain Mormon Concerns London Olympics Photos&Maps 2 Zubrin & Mars 7/28/12 Threats? Mars Stonewall Weather Goof by Mars Rover Remote Viewing Comet Lovejoy Space Shuttle Odd Shortsale Japan Tsunami Fukushima&End Meltdown Plutonium&H2O UFO Abduction Shutdown Deal WikiLeaks 1st Debate No Teleprompter Rodney King China in Space? Alien Hybrids? Bob Salas UFO MSL Sky Color Mars Sky Color Ashima/MIT&Mars Mars Base End of NASA Brain-Reading Brokow vs. Gingrich Newt Gingrich Santorum&Gays Roberts Vote Ron Paul Cain Withdraws Jeb Bush 2012 Assad's Wife French Election Basketball Court Islam's Judas Hamid Karzai Terror in France Mofaz&Netanyahu BeerSheba Attack George Soros Shalit Release Steve Jobs Social Security Barney Frank Michele Bachman Mineral Quake 9-11-2011 Lennon&Imagine Irene Flood Joplin Tornado Casey Anthony Steven Hawking Jeff Savage Eilat Attack Renfroe UFO Mt. Sinai Pics Rocket Defense Haiti Earthquake Giffords shot Impeach Obama? Obama Loss Qaddaffi&Obama Don't ask/tell? Internet Dangers Past Presidents Jon Huntsman Bush Memoirs Bin Laden New Civil War? Rahm Emanuel Roman Rahm Mayor Rahm Antimatter Planet Kepler22b Atomic Iran Peace Talks Abu Mazen U.S. Israel Rift Israeli ship-raid Iran Chicken Iran&Suez Canal Mousavvi Top Kill Fails Pakistan Flood Halliburton&Oil Mars Monolith Potter UFO 2 End of All Life IRS Attack Chemical Ali Oil Spill Oil and Life Airline Miracle Christmas Polish President Gaza Iron Wall TR-3B UFO Life on Mars Ark to Mars UFO Onion-Drive Wormholes Martian Life Olympus Mons MSL Mars Launch H Bomb Test Supercollider ANTIGRAVITY Robson&Jupiter Onion Drive Update NIKOLA TESLA PALIN RESIGNS CFR BrzezinskI IRAN WAR Gaza Invasion ZECHARIAH Statistics Permutation Control Text Obama&Islam NASA Director Michael Jackson To Muslims 2008 Election Clintons Clinton Weds Nuclear War? Baal Zephon B. Zephon&Ark Implications Jeremiah&Ark Vendyl Jones In Jerusalem? Al-Awlaki Death Ark Destroyed? Titus/Rome Knights Templar Mt. Nebo/Ireland? ELIYAHU RIPS Rabbi Glazerson Hawass&Permits Religious Tests Other Texts? Mayan Calendar Google&Privacy Nasrallah Elena Kagan Obama Nobel Obama&McCain Snooping Skip Tables Term Positions RABIN MURDER 27-August-2012 YASIR ARAFAT Hurricanes Walter K. York Romney&Netanyahu LINKS Roswell Angelic Doctor Joseph Smith Transgender Michelle? Mars SAM Buy ARK CODE ROFFMAN BIO Spiritual Custody Contents Annulled Ch. 1 Annulled Ch. 2 Annulled Ch. 3 Annulled Ch. 4 Annulled Ch. 5 Annulled Ch. 6 Annulled Ch. 7 Annulled Ch. 8 Annulled Ch. 9 Annulled Ch10 Annulled Ch11 Annulled Ch12 Annulled Ch13 Annulled Ch14 Annulled Ch15 Annulled Ch16 Annulled Ch17 Annulled Ch18 Annulled Ch19 Annulled Ch20 Annulled Ch21 Annulled Ch22 Annulled Ch23 Epilogue Custody press coverage

Experiments buried under mountains, flown on Space Shuttle STS-57, and possibly part of the new Space-X Falcon 9R rocket. (Updated on 12/22/2015)

FLASH: ON DECEMBER 21, 2015 SPACE X SUCCEEDED IN LANDING THEIR FALCON 9 BOOSTER BACK AT CAPE CANAVERAL. THE ARTICLE BELOW WAS PUBLISHED IN NOVEMBER, 2014.
 
       This page will explain the significance of encoding related to antigravity experiments conducted by Eugene Podkletnov.  It will also explore the possibility that antigravity is being worked into the Space-X Falcon 9R rockets being tested in 2014. The experiments conducted by Podkletnov involved the superfluid liquid Helium. Liquid Helium is used on the Falcon 9R, and Space Shuttle STS-57 carried out experiments related to transferring liquid Helium
       In April and May of 2014 I saw on the news that the launch of the first (and later the second) returnable Falcon 9R rockets were delayed because of helium leak leaks. Helium is not normally used in rockets. In a check on line I found that the helium is supposedly used for pneumatic decoupling of the first and second stages. The full Space-X concept is almost as far out as antigravity. WATCH WHAT THEY ARE TRYING TO DO HERE. Figure 1 below has as its axis term THE SUPERFLUID. HELIUM is at skip +1, WEIGHT is in the open text, and the reference to a CLOUD LIFTING may refer to what Podkletnov saw happening to tobacco smoke even one floor above his experiment. HELIUM is also on Figure 3, but only at skip -4. The axis term of Figure 3 is ANTIGRAVITY.

Figure 1 above and its probability spreadsheet below.

        Podkletnov is discussed in a 737-page textbook entitled Frontiers of Propulsion Science. It was published in February, 2009 by the American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronauts, Inc (AIAA). From hereon I shall refer to it simply as the textbook. It purports to be the first textbook in the field of Breakthrough Propulsion Physics. Podkletnov is mentioned in the index on pages xxiv, 9-10, 14-15, 237-239, and 242.  On page xxiv, on Figure 1, which sums up the contents of the text, his concept is listed as having had null results or shown to be not viable.  On page 10 it is stated that NASA’s Marshall Space Flight Center in Huntsville, Alabama, began its own study in an attempt to recreate Podkletnov configuration. The study ran from 1995 to 2002, but was unable to complete the needed test hardware with the resources available. Private funding supposedly did allow for a completed apparatus and published the results in 2003.  “Using equipment 50 times more sensitive than available to Podkletnov, the group found no evidence of a gravity-like force.” Podkletnov then made the assertion that a force beam could be created by applying high-voltage discharges near superconductors.  However, the claim is unsubstantiated according to Paul A. Gilster of the Tau Zero Foundation, who wrote Chapter 1 of the textbook.  Gilster does credit Podkletvov with bringing a combination of both energy and skepticism to the subject (of antigravity).  Chapter 5, written by George D. Hathaway of Hathaway Consulting Services, Toronto, Canada, has a more detailed analysis that will be discussed further below.

             According to Nick Cook, much of Podkletnov's work is being done in Russia. Indeed, while Nick Cook is not mentioned in the textbook’s index, on page 19 of Chapter 1 it is stated that, “Reports in Jane’s Defense Weekly that aerospace giant Boeing was investigating superconductivity effects related to Podkletnov’s work remain unconfirmed” (Cook, N., “”Anti-Gravity Propulsion Comes ‘Out of the Closet,’” Jane’s Defense Weekly, 29 July 2002), and, I might add, un-refuted.  Gilster goes on to state that, "the private nature of such potential work makes the prospects for disclosure unknown. 

      Chapter 5 of the textbook is entitled Gravitational Experiments with Superconductors: History and Lessons.  A cursory read of it makes clear the extreme difficulty in measuring slight changes to the gravitation field when dealing with low temperatures and rapidly spinning superconductors. Podkletnov used liquid helium while some analyses by others (as the diagram on Figure 2 shows) were done with liquid nitrogen.  Liquid helium is much colder than liquid nitrogen.

       In Nick Cook’s book, THE HUNT FOR ZERO POINT, beginning on page 182, there is a description of a World War II German experiment with “a bell-shaped device comprising two contra-rotating cylinders filled with mercury, or something like it, that emitted a strange pale light blue” that killed five people.  Eventually, between April 28 and May 4, 1945, 62 scientists working on the project were shot by the SS.

     The object was worked on deep underground at a Wencelas Mine site in Poland. On page 228 of Cook’s book, he asserts that the object, not only generated a torsion field in the process of producing gravity shielding, but it also bent space-time, making it a time machine. On page 232 he describes why such a (dangerous) device would be needed to be buried deeply. As described above, the man who attracted a firestorm of controversy about a successful antigravity experiment in 1992 was Eugene Podketnov. PODKLETNOV is the axis term on Figure 2 where we see that at the second lowest ELS of his name in the Torah Code, the last letter of his name begins the open text statement AND YOU STOOD UNDER THE MOUNTAIN AND THE MOUNTAIN BURNED WITH FIRE UNTO THE HEART OF HEAVEN. These kinds of experiments are both dangerous and in need of great security due to the potential for use in weapons systems. They are best conducted under mountains, just as our Space Command was located for a long time under Cheyenne Mountain in Colorado.     

Figure 2 - Podkletnov and a Deuteronomy 4:11 description reminiscent of where earlier antigravity research was reportedly done by the Nazis in Wencelas, Poland.

    On Figure 3 we find that the only encoding of the term ANTIGRAVIY in the Torah Code is crossed by Deuteronomy 32:22.  This verse states, “For fire will have been kindled in My nostrils and blaze to the lowest depths.  It shall consume the earth, AND SET ABLAZE THE FOUNDATIONS OF MOUNTAINS.”  So if encoding of Antigravity there is deliberate, then the location of that encoding seems to suggest that such an experiment may endanger the Earth.  Because antigravity is often associated with UFO propulsion, as in Paul Potter's book, GRAVITATIONAL MANIPULATION OF DOMED CRAFT, UFO Propulsion Dynamics, I sought UFO at a special case skip (+/- 1 or the absolute skip of the axis term). I found it at the same skip as ANTIGRAVITY. Figure 3 also has an ELS of HELIUM touch ANTIGRAVITY. Of course, even a helium balloon will appear to defy gravity and rise. In the open text is AND RISE. Two scientists (other than Podkletnov) are associated with antigravity. They are Nikola TESLA and Townsend T. BROWN. Both are present on Figure 3, with Brown's name found in the ELS of ANTIGRAVITY.


 

Figure 3 - The axis term ANTIGRAVITY, crossed by Deuteronomy 32:22 which also describes an area similar where original antigravity research was being done originally.

STATISTICAL SIGNIFICANCE OF FIGURES 1, 2 and 3. As per my standard protocol, no statistical significance is assigned to the axis terms, on Figure 1: THE SUPERFLUID, at its lowest ELS in unwrapped Torah, on Figure 2 PODKLETNOV at its 2nd lowest ELS in unwrapped Torah, and on Figure 3 ANTIGRAVITY at its lowest ELS in wrapped Torah.    
       Figure 2 does not merit a statistical discussion because the expression AND YOU STOOD UNDER THE MOUNTAIN AND THE MOUNTAIN BURNED WITH FIRE UNTO THE HEART OF HEAVEN was only noticed in an a-posteriori manner. When I saw it, it reminded me of the Wencelas Mine site in Poland, but I did not go looking for something like this before the experiment. However, while I cannot assign a statistical value to it Figure 2, I can assign significance to a similar phrase on Figure 3 because I then knew to look for something like it. Figure has the Deuteronomy 32:22 expression “For fire will have been kindled in My nostrils and blaze to the lowest depths.  It shall consume the earth, AND SET ABLAZE THE FOUNDATIONS OF MOUNTAINS.”  So, like Deuteronomy 4:11 we have a combination of mountains and fire. Had I found Deuteronomy 4:11 here I would have counted it, as I would also count an appearance of Genesis 22:2 which includes "offer him there for a burnt offering upon one of the mountains," and Exodus 32:12 which offers "slay them in the mountains." So we have a frequency of four phrases that might work on a matrix (Figure 3) that is 300 letters in area. There was about 1 chance in 254 that one of these expressions would appear on the matrix. Other terms on Figure 3 ranged from an in significant 1 chance in 1.3 (TESLA where I sought 5 spellings of the name) to 1 chance in 8.88 (HELIUM). Only UFO was at a special case skip (+/- 1 or the skip of the axis term as shown on the Figure), but it is composed of only three common letters, so it's easy to find. It was present against odds of about 7.2 to 1. Overall, Figure 3 was found against odds of about 129,087. In the full 638-letter matrix for Figure 1
    On Figure 3 we find that the only encoding of the term ANTIGRAVIY in the Torah Code is crossed by Deuteronomy 32:22.  This verse states, “For fire will have been kindled in My nostrils and blaze to the lowest depths.  It shall consume the earth, AND SET ABLAZE THE FOUNDATIONS OF MOUNTAINS.”  So if encoding of Antigravity there is deliberate, then the location of that encoding seems to suggest that such an experiment may endanger the Earth.  Because antigravity is often associated with UFO propulsion, as in Paul Potter's book, GRAVITATIONAL MANIPULATION OF DOMED CRAFT, UFO Propulsion Dynamics, I sought UFO at a special case skip (+/- 1 or the absolute skip of the axis term). I found it at the same skip as ANTIGRAVITY. Figure 3 also has an ELS of HELIUM touch ANTIGRAVITY. Of course, even a helium baloon will appear to defy gravity and rise. In the open text is AND RISE. Two scientists (other than Podkletnov) are associated with antigravity. They are Nikola TESLA and Townsend T. BROWN. Both are present on Figure 3, with Brown's name found in the ELS of ANTIGRAVITY. Only UFO was at a special case skip (+/- 1 or the skip of the axis term as shown on the Figure), but it is composed of only three common letters, so it's easy to find. It was present against odds of about 7.2 to 1.
        Overall, Figure 3 was found against odds of about 129,087. The most astounding match seen on Figure 1 where axis term THE SUPERFLUID is matched by HELIUM at Skip +1 (best case scenario) in a box that is only 110 letters in area. In all 304,805 letters of Torah HELIUM only occurs at Skip +1 twice. In the full 638-letter matrix for Figure 1 HELIUM was there at skip +1 against odds of about  239 to 1, but WEIGHT was found at Skip +1 against odds of about 13 to 1, so the combined odds against Figure 1 were about 3,212 to 1. No significance was assigned to AND THE CLOUD LIFTED because it was only found a-posteriori.